Wine-tasters are used to getting brickbats along with the bouquets
- by -
eMail send to a friend
share with a friend
Victoria Moore gives her opinion on wine tasters and awards.


 Here we go again. “Even experts can’t judge wine accurately,” ran a headline in a paper at the weekend. I rolled my eyeballs. They swivelled again yesterday when the Today programme took up cudgels, citing an American study published (five years ago, but don’t let that get in the way of giving wine connoisseurs a good hosing) in the Journal of Wine Economics. “Experts are accused of being random in the awarding of gold stars [for bottles of wine],” said Justin Webb crisply. “Are they just making it up?”

Forgive me for displaying a touch of sensitivity here. There is nothing the British public relishes more – except, perhaps, a story about an estate agent being gazundered or a criminal negligence lawyer losing a claim – than a study that seems to show so-called wine experts haven’t got a clue what they’re talking about.

So I will hold up my hands and say there is a tremendous variability when it comes to tasting wine.

My tasting ability fluctuates according to the time of day; it’s much sharper in the morning, which is a nuisance because tasting 100 wines before lunch leaves me foggy for the afternoon. I taste better on an empty stomach; hunger seems to sharpen the senses. Eating food also affects how a wine is perceived. Just try drinking a dry red after eating chocolate, or a delicate white after a curry and you’ll see what I mean.

And don’t put me in a bad mood or wind me up ahead of a tasting, because if you do I’m going to experience a surge of cortisol, the stress hormone, and every red wine I put in my mouth is going to taste tinny and thin and horrid.

To read more, click here



add a comment
  no comments - click "add comment"
The article above is distributed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License
You may copy, re-use or re-print any of this information as long as wine.co.za is quoted as source.
Any statements made or opinions expressed are the legal responsibility of the AUTHOR,
and do not necessarily reflect the views of WineNet (PTY) Ltd. or its sponsors.






buy wine online from our shop
R 295 bottle

La Motte Methode Cap Classique 2010

68% Pinot Nior, 32% Chardonnay
alc: 12.32  RS: 2.3  pH: 3.29
The dominant Pinot Noir in this wine shows in the colour with a champagne blush. A fine ... read more »